Most births in Queens hospitals go the way everyone hopes. When one doesn't, parents are left holding a newborn, a list of unfamiliar diagnoses and a question nobody in the hospital seems willing to answer directly: could this have been prevented?
This guide doesn't try to answer that for your family. It can't. What it does is lay out, as plainly as we can, the questions parents bring to a Queens birth injury lawyer in the first months, and the general answers under New York law. Read it at your own pace. Skip to the questions that matter to you.
1. What counts as a "birth injury"?
The phrase covers harm to a baby, or to the mother, that happens during pregnancy care, labor, delivery or the period right after birth. Not every injury that happens at birth is someone's fault. Some conditions are genetic, some come from infections or problems that nobody could have detected, and some happen even when every decision was correct.
A birth injury becomes a legal claim when the harm resulted from medical care that departed from accepted practice. That is the core of a medical malpractice case in New York: a departure from the standard of care, and proof that the departure caused the injury. Our medical malpractice practice page explains the general framework.
2. Which conditions come up most often?
- Hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE): brain injury caused by a lack of oxygen and blood flow around the time of birth. Babies with HIE may be treated with therapeutic cooling in the NICU.
- Cerebral palsy: a group of disorders affecting movement and muscle tone. Some cases are linked to oxygen deprivation during labor; many are not.
- Brachial plexus injuries, including Erb's palsy: damage to the nerves of the shoulder and arm, often associated with shoulder dystocia, when the baby's shoulder becomes stuck after the head is delivered.
- Skull fractures and bleeding associated with forceps or vacuum extraction.
- Injuries from delayed treatment of conditions like preeclampsia, infection or newborn jaundice.
3. How would anyone know whether the care was wrong?
By reading the records closely and having qualified physicians review them. In a labor and delivery case, the questions often include:
- What did the fetal heart rate monitoring show, and how quickly did the team respond to concerning patterns?
- Was there a delay in deciding on, or performing, a C-section?
- Were risk factors identified during prenatal care, such as gestational diabetes, high blood pressure, a large baby or a prior C-section, and was the delivery plan adjusted?
- Were forceps or a vacuum used, and was their use appropriate?
- How was a shoulder dystocia managed, and is the documented sequence of maneuvers consistent?
- Was the newborn evaluated and treated promptly, including cooling therapy when indicated?
New York requires a lawyer filing a malpractice suit to certify that they have consulted with a physician and concluded there is a reasonable basis for the case. That rule exists to keep weak cases out of court, and it means a responsible lawyer will not file without an expert review.
4. What records should we ask for?
Ask for the complete records, not a summary. That usually means:
- The mother's prenatal records from the OB-GYN practice or clinic.
- The hospital labor and delivery chart, including nursing notes and the full fetal monitoring strips.
- The baby's newborn and NICU records, including imaging like MRIs and head ultrasounds.
- Placental pathology, if the placenta was examined.
- Records from follow-up pediatric, neurology and early intervention providers.
Many hospitals keep electronic records that include audit trails showing when entries were made or changed. A lawyer can request those as part of a case. Patients have a right to their records under New York law, and hospitals may charge only a limited fee for copies.
5. How long do we have to bring a claim?
This is the question with the most moving parts. In general terms:
| Claim | General deadline |
|---|---|
| The baby's malpractice claim against a private hospital or doctor | Two and a half years under CPLR 214-a, but the infancy toll in CPLR 208 extends the time. For malpractice, that extension is capped at 10 years from the act or omission. |
| The mother's own malpractice claim | Generally two and a half years, with no infancy toll. |
| Claims involving a public hospital (for example, NYC Health + Hospitals facilities) | A notice of claim generally within 90 days, and a lawsuit generally within one year and 90 days, subject to tolling and court-ordered extensions. |
| Wrongful death of a newborn | Generally two years from death. |
The public hospital rules are the ones that catch families off guard. Queens has major public hospitals, and if your delivery took place in one, the 90-day clock is very short. Ask early.
6. Does the mother have her own claim?
She may. Injuries to the mother, such as a severe tear that was not properly repaired, a hemorrhage that was not managed promptly, an injury during a C-section, or harm from untreated preeclampsia, can support her own malpractice claim. Parents may also have a claim for the medical expenses they pay for the child's care while the child is a minor.
7. What is the Medical Indemnity Fund?
New York created the Medical Indemnity Fund in 2011. When a birth-related neurological injury case is resolved by a settlement or judgment, the Fund can pay the child's qualifying future medical expenses, instead of those costs being paid out of the lump-sum recovery. The rules are in Public Health Law Article 29-D, including § 2999-h.
In practice, this means a family's lawyer needs to understand how the Fund works, because it affects how future care is valued, documented and paid for. It does not replace other damages, like pain and suffering or loss of earning capacity.
8. What can a birth injury claim recover?
Depending on the case, damages may include:
- Past and future medical care, therapies, equipment and home modifications (some future medical costs may be paid through the Medical Indemnity Fund).
- Future lost earning capacity for the child.
- Pain and suffering.
- The parents' out-of-pocket expenses and lost time from work caring for the child, in appropriate cases.
Experts such as life care planners and economists often help project what a child will need over a lifetime. Our post on brain injury claims in Queens covers how life care plans work in serious neurological cases.
9. Will we have to go to court?
Many malpractice cases settle, but they are prepared as if they will be tried. For a child, any settlement must be approved by a court, which reviews whether it is fair and how the money will be protected. That often means a structured settlement, a supplemental needs trust or a restricted account. The court's role is to protect the child, and families generally find the process reassuring rather than adversarial.
10. What if the doctor apologized?
Families sometimes hear a doctor or nurse say "I'm sorry this happened." That is a human reaction, and it is not, on its own, an admission of malpractice. What matters is what the records and experts show. Don't let either an apology or a denial decide for you whether to ask questions.
11. Should we sign anything the hospital sends?
Before signing anything that mentions a release, a settlement or a waiver, speak with a lawyer. You can and should sign forms that let you get records and care. You should not give up rights without understanding them.
It's also wise not to post details about the delivery or your child's condition on social media while you are considering a claim. Defense lawyers do read it.
12. What should we do now?
- Focus on your baby's care. Ask about early intervention services through New York City, which are available for qualifying children under age three.
- Keep a journal of symptoms, appointments, therapies and what doctors tell you.
- Request records for both mother and baby.
- Note the hospital. If it is a public hospital, the 90-day notice deadline is your most urgent date.
- Talk to a lawyer who will have the records reviewed by qualified physicians before giving you a view.
A closer look: how an expert review actually works
Parents often picture a lawyer reading a chart and declaring a verdict. That isn't how a responsible review works. In a typical birth injury evaluation, the records go to physicians in the relevant specialties. An obstetrician looks at prenatal care, labor management and the decision-making around delivery. A maternal-fetal medicine specialist may weigh in on high-risk pregnancies. A neonatologist reviews the newborn's resuscitation and NICU care. A pediatric neurologist and a neuroradiologist may review the MRI to help estimate when a brain injury occurred, which can matter a great deal: an injury pattern consistent with a sudden event in the last hours of labor tells a different story than one consistent with a problem weeks earlier.
Those physicians are asked two separate questions. First, did the care depart from accepted practice? Second, if it did, did that departure cause the injury, or make it worse? A case needs a yes to both. Some reviews come back with a clear departure but no causal link, and some find a serious injury with no departure at all. A lawyer who tells you the results of that review honestly, even when the answer is no, is doing their job.
Early intervention, therapy and the record you're building
Whatever you decide about a claim, your child may qualify for services through New York City's Early Intervention Program, which serves eligible children from birth to age three with developmental delays or diagnosed conditions. Services can include physical, occupational and speech therapy, and special instruction. Ask your pediatrician or the NICU discharge team about a referral.
Those services help your child first. They also create a careful, dated record of your child's development: evaluations, goals, progress notes and therapists' observations. If a claim does go forward, that record often becomes some of the most persuasive evidence of what your child needs, now and later. Keep copies of every evaluation and every individualized plan.
How our firm helps families
We take a careful, unhurried approach with birth injury cases. We listen, gather records, and work with qualified medical professionals to understand what happened. If the evidence does not support a claim, we tell you so. If it does, we build the case with your child's long-term needs at the center.
Yakov Mushiyev & Associates offers free consultations in English, Russian and Spanish, at our Rosedale office, by video or at your home. There is no fee unless we win. Call 718.775.3110 or reach out online. If your family is also dealing with a different kind of injury, our guide to what to expect from a Queens injury attorney walks through the process from first call to settlement.
Directions to Yakov Mushiyev & Associates
Our office is at 1 Cross Island Plaza, Suite 325, Rosedale, NY 11422, in southeast Queens near the Queens–Nassau border. The map below shows the route from Jamaica Center, Queens. We also meet clients by video, at home or in the hospital.
Open turn-by-turn directions in Google Maps
Birth injury FAQ
Is cerebral palsy always caused by medical malpractice?
No. Many cases of cerebral palsy have causes unrelated to the delivery, including genetic factors, infections and events earlier in pregnancy. Some cases are linked to oxygen deprivation around birth that may have been preventable. Only a careful review of the records by qualified physicians can tell the difference.
How long do I have to file a birth injury lawsuit in New York?
A child's malpractice claim generally has two and a half years, extended by the infancy toll but capped at 10 years for malpractice. The mother's own claim generally has two and a half years. Public hospital claims require a notice of claim, generally within 90 days. Get advice early.
What is HIE and can it be a basis for a claim?
Hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy is a brain injury caused by reduced oxygen and blood flow around birth. It can support a claim if the evidence shows the medical team missed or responded too slowly to warning signs, such as concerning fetal heart rate patterns, and that a timely response would likely have prevented or reduced the injury.
Can I get my baby's fetal monitoring strips?
Yes. Fetal monitoring strips are part of the mother's labor and delivery record, and you can request them along with the rest of the chart. Ask for the complete strips, not a summary, and request the baby's newborn and NICU records separately.
Do I pay anything upfront to hire a Queens birth injury lawyer?
Not with our firm. Birth injury cases are handled on a contingency fee, which means we advance the costs of the case and are paid only from a recovery. New York caps contingency fees in medical malpractice cases on a sliding scale.